In my 30 years of training, from police K9s to family pets, one of the most heartbreaking situations I encounter is a high-drive dog in a home that’s completely unprepared for its needs. People see a beautiful Belgian Malinois or a stunning Border Collie and fall in love with the look, but they don’t see the engine inside. This is a classic violation of my first commandment: never pick a breed based on looks. You have to match the dog to your lifestyle and experience.
A high-drive dog isn't a bad dog; it's a dog with a purpose. These breeds were developed for intense work—herding, detection, protection. They have an off-the-charts need for mental stimulation and physical engagement. When that need isn't met, you see what most people call 'bad behavior.' It's not malice; it's a cry for help. The dog is essentially screaming, 'Give me a job to do!' This is where we often see the root cause of behavioral issues, and you have to address that, not just the symptom of chewing up your couch.
I see owners who think endless games of fetch will suffice, but that often just creates an adrenaline junkie. Faster is usually not better. These dogs need to learn how to turn on *and* turn off. This is where my structured crate training protocols are essential. The crate becomes a place of calm, not a punishment. We teach the puppy that a crazy fit is not the best way to get freedom.
Clarity is kindness. From day one, you need to establish structure. My leash walking stages, for example, are about creating a clear line of communication, not just preventing pulling. The dog learns to look to you for guidance. It's about setting the puppy up for success rather than failure. You can't overestimate your ability with these working breeds. If you're struggling, my second commandment is to seek guidance from a reputable professional trainer early. It's never too late to create a better life for you and your dog, but it starts with understanding and respecting the animal in front of you. Not allowing your dog to be a dog is a form of cruelty, even when it's unintentional.
